Skip to main content

Ask a Librarian

Find what you need in our searchable FAQ.

What is a peer-reviewed journal article?

53 views   |   0 Vote this question as useful.   0 Vote this question as not useful.   |   Last updated on Dec 14, 2020    Scholarly Journals Databases

 

  • Peer reviewed journal articles are original research, theoretical, or experimental analysis of a topic.
  • Peer reviewed journals contribute to the scholarly conversation on that topic.
  • These articles are written by subject experts, typically scholars with advanced degrees such as a PhD, and are read by other experts and students.
  • A journal is considered to be peer reviewed if its articles go through a rigorous editorial process that involves review and approval by three of the author's peers.
    • These peers are people who are experts in the same subject area and are recognized leaders in that field who have been asked to sit on the publication's editorial board.
    • The peer review process for journal articles ensures the quality of published scholarship.
    • During the review process, any identifying information about the author is removed (name, institution, etc.) to elimate bias or favoritism.
  • After the article has been reviewed, it may be accepted, sent back for further editing, or rejected. 
    • It is extremely difficult to be published in a peer-reviewed journal
  • Only scholarly journals can be peer reviewed. All peer reviewed journals are scholarly, but not all scholarly journals are peer reviewed.
    •  Newspapers, magazines, trade journals, and websites are not peer reviewed publications.
  • Not every article published in a peer reviewed journal is a research article. These journals also may contain book reviews and other content that are not peer reviewed research articles.